Top
Click the icons below for product information.

Caldwell Blind Man's Bluff

Description

This ain’t no bluff, you must try this cigar

Robert Caldwell has burst onto the boutique cigar scene like some sorta supernova, and it seems like there’s no stopping his meteoric rise. You see, he makes cigars his way…he scours farms across the globe for the best tobacco leaves, tests and retests his blends until he gets the exact flavors he’s looking for, and keeps production limited in an effort to deliver a superior product. My word is bond, son, and I’m telling you once you try a Caldwell cigar you will count yourself among his growing legion of fans.

Blind Man’s Bluff comes wrapped in an enticing Ecuadorian Habano leaf atop a refined Honduran Criollo binder, long-fillers from the Dominican and Honduras ramp up the intensity. Tasty notes of cedar, bread, and sweet spice all enter the fray with a long and cool finish topping off the experience. Do yourself a favor and pick this sucker up before everyone else beats you to it.

Click the icons below for product information.
Size
Pack
In Stock
MSRP
Price
Qty
Cart
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Robusto (5.0"x50)
Box of 20
In Stock
$195.04
| save $19.05 10% off
$175.99
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Robusto (5.0"x50)
Pack of 5
Backordered
$48.75
| save $1.76
$46.99
Profile
Shape
Robusto
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Toro (6.0"x52)
Box of 20
In Stock
$216.24
| save $21.25 10% off
$194.99
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Toro (6.0"x52)
Pack of 5
In Stock
$54.05
| save $2.06
$51.99
Profile
Shape
Toro
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Gordo
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Magnum (Gordo) (6.0"x60)
Box of 20
In Stock
$237.44
| save $23.45 10% off
$213.99
Profile
Shape
Gordo
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Profile
Shape
Gordo
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
Magnum (Gordo) (6.0"x60)
Pack of 5
In Stock
$59.35
| save $2.36
$56.99
Profile
Shape
Gordo
Wrapper
Ecuador Habano
Origin
Dominican Republic
Flavored
False
Pressed
False
Has Tip
False
Binder
Honduran
Filler
Dominican,  Honduran
Sweet
False
overall rating 4.66 out of 5 True { } True { } True { } Based on 50 Ratings
Customer Reviews of "Caldwell Blind Man's Bluff"
5 out of 5
5 Star
37
4 out of 5
4 Star
9
3 out of 5
3 Star
4
2 out of 5
2 Star
0
1 out of 5
1 Star
0
Showing 1-50 of50 Reviews
4 out of 5
Good taste and cigar
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Well blended, even burn, and great taste. Caldwell makes a great cigar and Blind Man's bluff is a great smoke and a good deal.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No1
5 out of 5
Excellent Cigar!!!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Expertly crafted. Perfect draw. This is my GO TO cigar from Caldwell. Medium bodied with a cedar and sweet spicyness. Buy a box if you are able!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
These cigars had a very good medium flavor, and all cigars had a clean burn thru the whole smoke. I will definitely buy this brand again.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Excellent smoke, gotta take your time with this one and enjoy it while it last.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Excellent stick with a nice spice from the Honduran criollo binder and filler. Gorgeous Ecuadorian wrapper with a faint honey finish.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Good smoke here! Thick chewy smoke output with beautiful construction and burn. Just the right amount of Spice from the Honduran tobacco. Ever so slight chocolate on the finish. Must have.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
The balance of flavors and draw were beautiful on these cigars.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
One of my favorites
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
smooth flavor
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
Good smoke for the price
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great medium to full body cigar with a great draw.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Very enjoyable Med bodied cigar.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Caldwell is quickly becoming my go to brand. Blind Man's Bluff is a fantastic smoke with great flavors in a medium strength cigar. This will be a regular in the humidor going forward.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
One of my favorite smokes. Keep coming back to this cigar & it never lets me down.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This. Cigar. Is.Fire. Loved it from the cold draw to the last nub. This is my favorite Caldwell. It was smooth, flavorful, and left my mouth watering and wanting more!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Unbelievable cigar, medium to full great flavor. Just started smoking Caldwells this year and they are at the top of my list Caldwell, Viaje and Padron my fav 3 brands. But the Caldwell collection the best so far. Last Tsar number one though!!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Caldwell doesn’t disappoint I like this cigar after a meal
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Rich, rich flavor
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
These are on my repeat purchase list.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Found Caldwell within last year and place them up there withDrew Estates.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Good smoke
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
I got these in cigar fest. Very smooth, same flavor throughout, I would say it’s a beginner cigar. If you’re looking for different flavors along the way, if you want enjoy more in the middle and thickness of the smoke, that’s not for you. Good for the price that you pay and well worth the value of the cigar.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
What a nice smooth cigar. Burns well and even. Nice draw,not too loose or too tight. Ordered 2 boxes
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Smooth, easy draw. Nice, slight hints of spice. Nothing too crazy, but there. Worth giving a try.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Received one of these at cigar fest and enjoyed very much so I bought a box. I find this cigar very flavorful and a pleasure to smoke.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This is my favorite non-cuban cigar. Very complex in flavor. Sweet, mild and almost creamy at times.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Very Consistent draw, tastes good to the end. Burns evenly
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This cigar is a medium to full bodied and has flavors of coco and is not to spicy, A great smoke when you just want to relax.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Wow! Great cigar. Tried one of these in a CO sampler and fell in love with it. Excellent construction. Very thick, creamy smoke. Notes of creamy coffee, cocoa and caramel, yes caramel after the halfway mark My new favorite stick. You don't even have to retrohale to taste it. Retrohale it to get all the delicious flavors.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great smoke. My go to all the time. Def buying again.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
4 out of 5
Smooth and great body.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
One of my favorites
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
The per-light so nice. Floral old world notes. The draw was effortless beautiful. And the leather and some chocolate and spicy hit the my pallet in waves for smokey delight. A very nice involving cigar. Construction was excellent :-)
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes2
No0
5 out of 5
Great smoke at an awesome price.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Great taste, even burn and overall fantastic cigar for the price. would definitely recommend it to anyone !
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
Not what I was expecting from this cigar, very bland no transitions, not worth all the hype it was built up to be in my opinion!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This is a very enjoyable cigar. Caldwell continues to impress. They are making waves and deservingly so!
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes1
No0
5 out of 5
Nice draw burns great taste awesome!
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
The reason I reordered this cigar is that it stays with you to the end no harshness towards the end like other I have had Nice draw
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
Nice construction, beautiful cigar, even burn, but I was not impressed. I've tasted much better cigars from Caldwell, Co. This one left me scratching my head. It was just a flat smoke and very one dimensional. There were no transitions in flavors, which I'm use to receiving from this company. I'll let the others sit for a couple of months in my humidor and see what develops, but I don't think there's much to work with flavors wise for a better profile later.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes2
No0
4 out of 5
Great Smoke! Subtle flavor that sneaks up on you. Might be hard for a newer smoker to appreciate the subtle flavors, but a seasoned puffer will really enjoy it.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Always a great cigar
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
One of the best non-rated cigars I've smoked lately.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
3 out of 5
I wanted to love this cigar, I really did. I had heard so many good things. Ultimately, it wasn't a bad cigar by any means. The cigar is was medium bodied, but flat and lifeless. I was hoping for some flavor profile to emerge, but it never did. Just an average cigar that left me unimpressed.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes2
No0
5 out of 5
It was a smooth, satisfying smoke.
verifiedverified buyer
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
Very good smoke well balanced
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
5 out of 5
This is a very unique cigar. Very enjoyable! Excellent construction, as well as flawless draw. You get a salted Carmel, spice, cedar, and pretzel flavors on the palette. I would recommend this to anyone looking for a great botique cigar.
Was this helpful?
Yes0
No0
Hide Reviews